According to a report, consumers have been left with multi-billion-pound bills due to a catalogue of mistakes at Ofgem.

Citizens Advice claims that for close to ten years, the regulator has failed to take action against unfit suppliers of energy, leaving this market open to this year’s surge in wholesale prices.

According to the charity, market participants were left in an uncertain position by missed opportunities and mistakes that led to gas prices rising in 2021.

Since the rise in prices, 26 suppliers have now collapsed, hitting four million households and leaving consumers with a bill of £2.6billion – excluding the £1.7billion of taxpayer money set aside for Bulb.

A catalogue of errors at Ofgem has left consumers with a multi-billion pound bill, a report says

Report says that consumers are being left holding a bill of multi-billion pounds due to an array of errors by Ofgem.

As a result, this will cost the average household around £94.

Citizens Advice claimed that Ofgem had only conducted one formal investigation into customer service because of the decline in customer service during the years preceding the crisis.

The enforcement powers weren’t used 

According to the charity, Ofgem has not used its power to prevent suppliers from taking on customers for customer service issues since February 2019

New supplier monitoring and financial checks were introduced by the watchdog in early 2021. They also offer protections to customers of fallen suppliers.

Only one of the twenty suppliers who failed between August 2021 and November 2021 required a Customer Continuousity Plan. This is also known as a living will.

Citizens Advice says that the percentage of Ofgem enforcement officers fell 25% in the years preceding the crisis. 

Because of regulatory failures, there was a culture that didn’t comply with evidence of licence violations. They also failed to take prompt or missing action on matters such as billing accuracy, phone access for customers, and providing prepayment options.

Opportunities missed 

Charity says that there have been many opportunities missed to reform the market. 

Citizens Advice expressed repeated concern about the financial viability and poor practices of new suppliers entering the market between 2010-2019.

The formal review of licensing that credits new suppliers was requested by the committee as soon as possible in 2013.

Ofgem didn’t conduct any review of the new entry rules until 2018. This came after eleven supplier failures. For firms that were already on the market, it took another two years for new regulations to be introduced.

According to the charity, poor business practices are rampant. Many companies show clear evidence that they cannot afford financial support, and some even run out of their homes.

Citizens Advice said it raised repeated concerns about poor practice and financial viability

Citizens Advice said it raised repeated concerns about poor practice and financial viability

Customers money is used to support suppliers 

Citizens Advice warns that financial weakness was evident long before the current crisis. A number of suppliers were dependent on customers’ credit for working capital. 

Ofgem’s own analysis showed suppliers held a total of £1.4billion in surplus credit in 2018, while other research suggested that some consumer balances were excessive.

People who contacted Citizens Advice for support, after their supplier failed, had average credit balances of £353, with some customers saying their energy supplier was holding over £1,000 of their money. 

According to Ofgem, an average bill payer needs only £150 in credit to cover typical winter usage.

Citizens Advice says there are lessons to be learned from rising energy prices, which will increase by hundreds of Pounds next April.

This charity has called for an independent investigation of market collapse causes, including Ofgem’s enforcement and compliance approach and reforms to make sure companies are able to trade.

The new “consumer duty” is similar to the one introduced by Financial Conduct Authority. It holds companies responsible for customer outcomes.

Citizens Advice suggested that Ofgem, Government, and Ofgem take action to prevent consumers being subject to unnecessarily large increases in bills due to supplier failures.

Chief Executive of Citizens Advice, Clare Moriarty stated that Energy customers now face a multibillion pound bill. It is due to Ofgem’s failure to take control of the market and deal with rule-breaking suppliers.

“Recent wholesale price hikes could have been difficult to deal with in any circumstance, but they don’t have to have resulted in the collapse or dissolution of a third the companies that were on the market.

“It is now evident that reform is necessary – this isn’t about avoiding another crises.

It is more difficult to get to net zero if consumers have low confidence in the market or believe they are being cheated. It is crucial to reform the system in order not only to avoid the same mistakes as the past, but also for the future.

Avro Energy’s Citizens Advice is available 

Citizens Advice expressed concerns to Ofgem on 10 occasions between 2018 and 2021 regarding Avro Energy. The company’s customer base has grown from 210,000.00 to 590,000.

Citizens Advice wrote a formal notice to Ofgem in 2018, raising concerns over Avro’s potential violations of license conditions. 

Avro also had multiple complaints about transfer blocking, billing errors, and poor customer services between 2019-2021.

In September 2021 Avro collapsed, owing creditors £250million and leaving consumers with a £679million bill.

Administrator reports revealed that the company was dependent on credit balances for its daily operations, and failed to buy enough energy ahead of time from wholesale markets (‘hedging’).  

Ofgem however claims that it has protected customers through its Supplier of Last Resort Scheme. Consumers with over-subscribed providers are moved to another supplier automatically.  

Ofgem spokeswoman said that “Ofgem has as its top priority to protect energy consumers” and they understand the problems faced by businesses and households in light of unprecedented global gas price increases.

Over four million people have been protected by ‘Ofgem. They are moved to new suppliers and don’t worry about energy supplies. Credit balances also remain intact. 

“In addition, this price cap protects millions more against the full effect of high gasoline prices this winter.

“However, though, we recognize that reforms to the energy market are urgently needed – this system was not built for such an extreme market event. 

“Building upon the October approach at Energy UK, and the subsequent open letter from the industry, we’ll be making changes in the coming weeks that demonstrate our seriousness in addressing the speed of change required, concerns about the financial resilience, and fair prices through the price cap.

“We are happy to collaborate with all consumers groups including Citizen Advice and the Government to implement the necessary changes as we share the common goal of protecting energy consumers in the present and future.”

A spokesperson said that Odgem would continue to make greater use of its information gathering power to assess supplier financial performance more frequently, as well as to audit them, and will apply greater scrutiny. 

In light of the increased risks, the regulator will set higher expectations for suppliers regarding capital investments.

It will also require a stronger approach for assessing suppliers’ pricing, operational capability, and investment plans as they hit the milestones of 50,000 domestic customers. 

This article might contain affiliate links. We may receive a commission if you click them. This is money helps fund it and we keep it for free. Articles are not written to sell products. No commercial affiliation can affect our editorial independence.